When you go for a large-sized dog breed for you, then you come up with several alternatives like xl bully, Rottweiler, Bullmastiff, German Shepherd, Cane Corso and many more.
But it is not necessary that all of these breeds may be ideal for you because of their distinct bloodlines and personality. So, in this article we will present two amazing breeds and our topic of discussion will be : XL Bully vs German Shepherd Comparison.
You need to consider several factors including size, temperament, genes, coat type, behavior etc. while choosing the perfect one for you ! Apart from this, another significant factor is your needs and lifestyle.
So,choose the one that best fits your lifestyle.
Table of Contents
Which dog breed is best : XL American bully or German Shepherd
The answer to this question is not the same for everyone as it entirely depends upon the features you are looking for in a dog.
Hence, we have provided you with a comparative guide on xl bully vs German shepherd. By doing your research upon both characteristics, size, health concerns, temperament etc., you will be able to make the best choice for you.
Here, we assure you to have all the necessary information which will enable you to make a wise and informative decision.
Origin and Short history of XL Bully and German Shepherd
All types of american bully, including xl bully, are a recently popularized dog breed and originated between the 1980s and 1990s in the United States.
The American bully breed was recognized by the American Bully Kennel Club (ABKC) at first in 2004.
These are large-sized canines which have been developed by crossbreeding different popular bully breeds, including Pitbull, Staffordshire bull terriers, bullmastiffs and other types of bulldogs. They are known for their friendly nature and balanced temperament.
As the name suggests, the German Shepherd is a pure dog breed that originated in Germany in the late 19th century. Breeders tried to standardize the breed to preserve the traits which helped in the task of herding sheep and protecting their flocks from other animals. German shepherds are also known as Alsatian Wolf Dogs or Alsatians.
Comparison : XL Bully vs German Shepherd
Both xl american bully and German shepherd are amazing dog breeds to choose from. So, let’s have our look at some major differences in the xl bully and German shepherd which will help you in making an ideal decision.
1. Size
Considering the size of dogs is one of the most important aspects of choosing a perfect dog breed for you. The space to be occupied, the food diet and their exercise requirements greatly depend upon the size of dogs.
Large sized dogs will acquire more space, require more calories and exercise requirements in comparison to smaller breeds.
On average, a male american bully xl can reach 20–23 inches at their shoulders and a female xl american bully can stand 19–22 inches tall. It ranges between 70 and 120 pounds.
On the other hand, the German Shepard is a medium to large sized dog breed weighing about 50–90 pounds. The standard height of the German shepherd is 24–26 inches for males and 22–24 inches for females.
2. Temperament
If we talk about the temperament of these breeds, then the American xl bully is a highly affectionate and friendly dog breed while the German shepherd is a loyal and protective dog breed.
American xl bully dogs love to play with kids and other pets. They are also protective towards their family members. Thus, they can be considered excellent guard dogs.
German Shepherd dogs are not recommended to be appropriate with small children or other pets. They may be difficult to handle for first time dog owners as they require firm and consistent training.
Both can be a companion breed with a decent temperament if they are provided with proper training and early socialization.
3. Types or varieties
The American Bully Kennel Club (ABKC) divided and registered four different types of american bully based on their height and weight. They are classic, standard, pocket and xl american bully.
Later, Xxl american bully also got added as one of the types. But it has not been recognized as a standard breed by any kennel club yet.
However, German Shepherds were mainly divided into two varieties, including a working line and a show line. Then, each of the two categories is divided into several subtypes.
Working line German shepherd dogs are categorized into three subtypes :
- West German Working Line
- East German Working Line
- Czech Working Line
Working lines are mainly used for special purposes, like for search and rescue operations and military services.
On the other hand, the show lines German shepherd consists of two groups :
- American/ Canadian Show Line
- European/ West German Show Line
Showlines are more friendly and affectionate canines. So, they can be perfect as family dogs.
4. Colour
Another least significant factor to consider while selecting a particular breed is the color. Both the breeds come in a variety of colors and shades too.
Different varieties of coat color of xl bully include:
- Fawn
- Black
- Blue
- Brindle
Some of the most common coat color patterns found in German shepherd dogs are :
- White
- Black
- Black and tan
- Black and red
- Blue
- Liver and tan
- Bicolor (black with cream-coloured heels)
- Sable or grey
5. intelligence level
Quick learning capacity and overall training depends upon the dog’s intelligence level (I.Q).
The Xl American bully is an intelligent breed which can learn easily but sometimes, they may become stubborn.
Thus, owners of these dogs should not be either overstrict or too lenient. Instead, they require consistent training and exercises. Positive reinforcement like rewards can be provided for their desirable behavior.
German shepherds are the most intelligent canines. They are at the top in the list of the smartest dogs. These dogs are excellent in the field of memory recall, quick learning and problem-solving.
The Wechsler Dog Intelligence Scale (WDIS) is a test specifically designed for checking the intelligence level of dogs.
6. Food and diet
Food and nutritional requirements are necessary to consider while choosing a pet dog for you. The food budget varies as per the individual breed. Larger dogs will consume more food than smaller breeds.
The american xl bullies are huge sized and heavy muscular build canines which are to be provided with a high protein-rich and healthy fat-rich balanced diet.
At least 30% protein is to be included in their routine food diet. Vitamins and minerals support the immune system of xl bullies.
On the contrary, German shepherds are medium to large sized dogs and also require a standard food diet but not as specialized as xl bully dogs. These dogs also need to be fed with rich protein and fat content to maintain their high energy level.
Remember a healthy food diet influences the smoothness of fur, mental state and also helps in reducing the risk of health issues.
7. Health issues
When we go through different breeds of dogs to select one as our pet, then, it’s crucial to be well aware of the health concerns related to different dogs. It will also assist in choosing the appropriate pet dog for your family.
Both American bully XL and German shepherd are highly prone to some health issues like elbow dysplasia and hip dysplasia.
American bully xl health problems :
American XL bullies are likely to suffer from some health diseases including :
- Hip dysplasia
- Elbow dysplasia
- Heart diseases
- Hypothyroidism
- Eye problems
- Skin diseases
- Dental issues
- Allergies like food allergy and environmental allergy
- Liver diseases
- Cancer
German Shepherd health issues :
- Hip dysplasia
- Elbow dysplasia
- Bloat
- Epilepsy
- Degenerative myelopathy
- Cancer
- Exocrine Pancreatic Insufficiency (EPI)
- Allergies
Consult the vet immediately if you detect any changes or signs of health issues in your pet.
Price or Cost
If we compare the price of xl bully dogs and German shepherd dogs, then there is no significant difference in pricing between them.
The cost of xl bully ranges from $1500 to $3500 while the price for German shepherd canines may vary between $2000 and $3500.
However, the cost may vary depending upon factors such as size, type of breed, genetic contribution, reputation of breeders and breeding standards.
The cost of these breeds does not only include their purchasing cost. Other expenses include their food diet, health care, grooming, brushing etc.
Lifespan
The lifespan is also one of the factors which need to be considered before choosing a companion dog.
So, if we look at the life duration of these two breeds, then the lifespan of a German shepherd dog is slightly longer than the xl bully dogs.
The xl american bully can live for the average duration of about 10–12 years. On the other hand, German shepherd dogs can live for about 13 years.
Genetics is a major factor which determines the life expectancy of any dog breed. Apart from this, other factors such as a balanced diet, grooming, regular exercises and health care also contribute in maximizing the continuity of their life.
Factors affecting the dog’s lifepan
Here is a list of factors affecting the life expectancy of dogs :
- Genetics
- Gender
- Dog’s size
- Living conditions
- Health
- Infections
- Exercises
- Diet
Few tips for choosing the right dog for you
If you are thinking of getting either a xl bully or a German shepherd as a pet, then you should consider the following suggestions before making a final decision:
1.Consider the following questions
Firstly, consider the following questions before making a final decision :
- Are you looking for a companion or a guard dog?
- Do you have time to provide consistent training and exercises ?
- Do you have experience with dogs?
- Do you have enough space in your home for a dog to play and rest?
- Will you be able to afford the cost of the dog?
2.Do proper research
After you get all the answers to the above questions, do thorough research about the ancestry and health concerns of dogs.
3.Ensure about the registered kennel club
Try to get a dog from registered kennel clubs. If you have decided to opt for a German shepherd after the above research, then ensure the breeder is registered with the kennel club.
On the other hand, if you have opted for American bully XL, then be sure to have an ABKC registered dog.
4.Choose a reputable breeder
Search for a reputable breeder who follows high breeding standards while breeding. It is crucial to get all the genuine genetic information about the canine.
A well recognized breeder can only provide you with a guarantee of a healthy and disease-free pet.
Frequently asked questions
Q1.Who is stronger: German Shepherd or American Bully?
Ans. Both are powerful dog breeds. German shepherds are mainly used in search and rescue operation & military services. Xl american bully is an excellent guard dog for the family.
Q2.How powerful are XL bullies?
Ans. Xl american bullies have a bite force of about 305 PSI, which is considered one of the highest bite force of bully breeds.
Q3.Which dog is more powerful than a pitbull?
Ans. Rottweilers
Q4 What are different types of german shepherds?
Ans. German Shepherds were mainly divided into two types: working line and show line. Then, each of the two categories is divided into several subtypes.
Hey there! I am Raj Saraf, a 23-year-old guy from India behind this awesome blog. Currently, I am pursuing my Master’s degree in English literature. Being a great admirer of this fascinating American bully dog breed, I did extensive and comprehensive research to my optimal level. During this, I got to know about some new and interesting facts about them, which encouraged me to go ahead. Moreover, I am fond of sharing my experiences and knowledge with you all! I hope you enjoy reading my blogs, and feel free to share any experiences or opinions about this amazing breed in the comments section below.
